Hayward vs Pentair Sand Filter - Which Should You Buy?
The short answer
Hayward Pro Series and Pentair Tagelus and Sand Dollar filters are close in price and performance. The differences come down to lateral design, valve options, and warranty. Here is the breakdown.
Hayward Pro Series S244T Sand Filter
The Pro Series S244T hits the sweet spot for mid-size residential pools: a corrosion-proof tank, a self-cleaning lateral design, and wide parts availability. Pentair's Tagelus is an equally strong choice, but Hayward's parts are easier to source for most owners.
In This Guide
The Short Answer
Hayward and Pentair both make excellent sand filters, and the quality gap is small. Hayward’s Pro Series wins on parts availability and a self-cleaning lateral design. Pentair’s Tagelus and Sand Dollar win on tank durability and an easy clamp closure. Pick by tank size, dealer support, and whatever brand matches your existing pump and equipment.
How the Two Brands Line Up
Both companies build sand filters across small, medium, and large pool sizes. Hayward’s main residential line is the Pro Series, sold as S2xxT models, with the larger ProGrid name used on its DE filters. Pentair’s sand filters are the Tagelus and the smaller Sand Dollar, with the Triton name covering its larger fiberglass-wound tanks.
The table compares the popular mid-size models most homeowners choose.
| Spec | Hayward Pro Series S244T | Pentair Tagelus TA60D |
|---|---|---|
| Tank size | 24 in | 24 in (TA60) |
| Filter area | ~3.1 sq ft | ~3.1 sq ft |
| Flow rate | Up to ~55 gpm | Up to ~58 gpm |
| Sand required | ~250 lb | ~250 lb |
| Lateral design | Self-cleaning radial laterals | Under-drain with laterals |
| Valve | Vari-Flo top or side mount | Clamp-style top mount |
| Tank closure | Bolted flange | Clamp band |
| Warranty | ~1 year | ~1 to 3 years by model |
| Street price | ~$500 to 650 | ~$500 to 650 |
Lateral Design and Filtration
Both brands trap particles in the 20 to 40 micron range, which is normal for sand. The difference is in how the laterals distribute water and resist channeling. Hayward’s Pro Series uses radial laterals it markets as self-cleaning, meant to spread flow evenly and reduce dead spots. Pentair’s under-drain design is proven and durable, with laterals that are straightforward to replace.
In real use, both filter water to the same clarity. Neither matches a DE or cartridge filter for fineness, which is the trade you make for sand’s low maintenance. If you are still weighing media types, our DE filter vs sand filter vs cartridge comparison covers that decision.
Valves and Closures
Valve and closure design is where owners feel the difference day to day.
Hayward uses the Vari-Flo multiport valve, available in top-mount or side-mount versions. Parts and spider gaskets are widely stocked. The tank closes with a bolted flange that is secure but slower to open.
Pentair pairs its filters with a clamp-style valve and a clamp band tank closure. Many owners find the clamp faster to open for the seasonal sand check. Pentair’s molded tanks have a strong durability reputation.
For step-by-step backwashing on each brand, see how to backwash a Hayward pool filter and how to backwash a Pentair pool filter.
Warranty and Parts Availability
Warranties are similar, generally 1 to 3 years on the tank depending on the exact model and where you buy. The bigger practical factor is parts. Hayward’s enormous installed base means laterals, gaskets, and valves are easy to find at any pool store. Pentair parts are also widely available but can take an extra day to source in some regions.
Which One to Buy
If you want the easiest parts hunt and a self-cleaning lateral design, choose Hayward Pro Series. If you value a durable molded tank and a fast clamp closure for seasonal sand checks, choose Pentair Tagelus. If you already run one brand’s pump and equipment, staying in that ecosystem simplifies service. When the buying decision is settled, the sand itself matters too, so check the best pool filter sand options before you load the tank.
Related Guides
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Hayward or Pentair a better sand filter?
Are Hayward and Pentair sand filters interchangeable?
What size sand filter do I need?
How long do Hayward and Pentair sand filters last?
Which brand is cheaper, Hayward or Pentair?
Our team combines 15+ years of hands-on pool maintenance experience with rigorous product testing. We own and test every piece of equipment we recommend — and we do not accept payment for positive reviews.